BLACK mobile logo

california

community

Newsom’s Plan for New State Education Commissioner Draws Support, Raises Questions About Student Achievement

July 7, 2026

California lawmakers have approved Governor Gavin Newsom's plan to restructure the state's education leadership by creating a new Governor-appointed Education Commissioner position that will take over management of the California Department of Education from the independently elected State Superintendent of Public Instruction. The restructuring, established through AB 181 and SB 111, aims to modernize governance and improve accountability amid persistent achievement gaps, with more than half of students failing to meet English language arts standards and nearly two-thirds falling short in mathematics. While supporters argue the change creates clearer lines of authority and responsibility for educational outcomes, critics including the California Teachers Association contend there is no evidence that reorganization alone will improve student performance and warn it concentrates too much power in the Governor's office.

Who is affected

  • California's 6+ million public school students, particularly Black and Latino students experiencing achievement gaps
  • The State Superintendent of Public Instruction (currently Tony Thurmond), whose executive authority is being transferred
  • California's 1,000+ school districts
  • The California Department of Education staff
  • The State Board of Education, which is expanding from 11 to 13 members
  • Teachers represented by the California Teachers Association
  • Future Governors who will appoint and control the Education Commissioner
  • California voters who elect the State Superintendent
  • The California Legislative Black Caucus and other legislative members
  • School administrators and education advocacy organizations

What action is being taken

  • California lawmakers have approved the creation of an Education Commissioner position through AB 181 and SB 111
  • The Governor will appoint an Education Commissioner subject to Senate confirmation
  • The State Board of Education is being expanded from 11 to 13 members
  • Executive control of the California Department of Education is being transferred from the elected State Superintendent to the appointed Commissioner
  • The legislation is moving from policy to implementation

Why it matters

  • This restructuring represents a fundamental shift in California's education governance and democratic accountability. With more than half of students failing to meet English language arts standards and nearly two-thirds falling short in mathematics—particularly impacting Black students with the state's lowest proficiency rates—supporters believe clearer lines of authority will improve outcomes for California's 6+ million public school students. However, the change also concentrates significant power in the Governor's office by replacing an independently elected constitutional officer with an appointed official, potentially setting a precedent for weakening other elected statewide offices and the state's system of checks and balances. The effectiveness of this major governance change will ultimately depend on whether it actually improves student achievement or merely reorganizes the administrative structure without addressing the underlying educational challenges.

What's next

  • California voters will elect a new Governor and a new State Superintendent of Public Instruction in November 2026
  • The new education leadership structure takes effect on January 15, 2027
  • The Education Commissioner must submit an interim report on a second phase of education governance reform by June 30, 2027
  • The Commissioner must provide final recommendations to the Governor and Legislature by October 1, 2027

Read full article from source: The San Diego Voice & Viewpoint