When Stephen A. Smith Speaks, White Power Listens

December 19, 2025

Joy Reid publicly criticized Stephen A. Smith after he characterized her MSNBC departure as a ratings failure, accusing him of being paid substantially to denigrate Black people and women for predominantly white executives. Smith had dismissed Reid's show performance and also attacked Texas Congresswoman Jasmine Crockett, questioning her congressional work and criticizing her communication style, which drew widespread backlash from public figures and social media users.

Who is affected

Joy Reid (former MSNBC host)
Stephen A. Smith (sports commentator)
Texas Congresswoman Jasmine Crockett
Black viewers and communities
Crockett's congressional constituents
Black women specifically targeted by Smith's commentary
Social media commentators Don Salmon and former NBA star Stephen Jackson

What action is being taken

Joy Reid is publicly calling out Stephen A. Smith's behavior and motivations
Jasmine Crockett is continuing her congressional work and focusing on her constituents
Social media users and public figures are criticizing Smith's commentary
Crockett is running for Texas Senate

Why it matters

This situation highlights how media figures with large platforms can perpetuate harmful narratives about Black people, particularly Black women, while being financially rewarded by major media companies. It reveals systemic issues where Black commentators may receive substantial compensation for criticizing their own community in ways that align with corporate or political interests. The controversy also demonstrates the ongoing tension between authentic Black advocacy and commentary that serves to undermine Black voices and achievements, particularly in the current political climate where the administration is accused of working to silence Black perspectives.

What's next

No explicit next steps stated in the article

Read full article from source: The San Diego Voice & Viewpoint