BLACK mobile logo

michigan

politics

Half of American women support abolishing ICE, polling shows

January 14, 2026

Following the fatal ICE shooting of Minneapolis resident Renee Good, a new YouGov/Economist poll reveals that half of American women now support abolishing Immigration and Customs Enforcement, a dramatic increase from 28 percent in June. Democratic lawmakers, particularly progressive women in Congress, are pushing various proposals ranging from complete elimination of the agency to implementing specific reforms like restricting excessive force and improving officer identification. However, the party remains internally divided on how aggressively to pursue these changes, with centrist Democrats warning that abolition messaging could be "politically lethal" while progressives argue the public demands serious accountability.

Who is affected

  • Renee Good, the 37-year-old American citizen fatally shot by ICE
  • American women (50 percent supporting ICE abolishment)
  • Democratic politicians navigating divisive party positions
  • Congressional Progressive Caucus members
  • Immigration enforcement officers and ICE agents
  • DHS Secretary Kristi Noem (facing impeachment articles)
  • Communities subject to immigration enforcement operations
  • Voters in competitive 2026 midterm races

What action is being taken

  • Rep. Shri Thanedar is preparing an upcoming proposal to eliminate ICE
  • Lawmakers are suggesting reforms to curb excessive force and improve officer identification
  • Rep. Robin Kelly and over 50 colleagues filed articles of impeachment against DHS Secretary Kristi Noem on Tuesday
  • Senator Chris Murphy is proposing additional restrictions on ICE and building a coalition for voting leverage
  • Democrats are messaging about the incident and ICE's role
  • Congress is gearing up for a spending battle this month

Why it matters

  • This represents a significant shift in public opinion on immigration enforcement, with polling showing for the first time that more Americans support than oppose abolishing ICE. The fatal shooting of an American citizen on camera has intensified scrutiny of the agency's practices and accountability mechanisms. The issue has major political implications for Democrats heading into 2026 midterms, as they must balance responding to growing constituent demands for ICE accountability against concerns that abolition messaging could alienate moderate voters. The debate also highlights fundamental questions about how immigration enforcement should function in the United States, especially given that ICE has only existed since 2003 and its responsibilities could potentially be handled through other means.

What's next

  • Congress is preparing for a spending battle this month where ICE and DHS funding will be debated. Rep. Shri Thanedar plans to introduce a proposal to eliminate ICE. Senator Chris Murphy is working to build a coalition for future voting leverage on restrictions. Democrats need to determine their messaging strategy for 2026 campaigns regarding ICE reform or abolishment.

Read full article from source: The 19th