BLACK mobile logo

virginia

politics

US judge says government 'missteps' may have tainted Comey case

November 17, 2025

A federal judge has raised serious concerns about potential government misconduct in the Trump administration's prosecution of former FBI Director James Comey, who faces charges of making false statements and obstruction of justice. Judge William Fitzpatrick determined that prosecutor Lindsey Halligan, who was quickly appointed by Trump and obtained an indictment within three days, may have made misleading statements to the grand jury that could have compromised the integrity of the proceedings. The judge granted Comey's defense team unprecedented access to all grand jury materials, including transcripts and audio recordings, to protect the defendant's rights.

Who is affected

  • James Comey (former FBI Director, defendant)
  • James Comey's defense team
  • Judge William Fitzpatrick
  • Lindsey Halligan (lead prosecutor/interim US attorney)
  • Justice Department lawyers
  • Grand jurors involved in the case
  • Donald Trump (US President who called for the prosecution)

What action is being taken

  • The Justice Department is appealing against Judge Fitzpatrick's order
  • Justice Department lawyers are ordered to release grand jury materials to Comey's defense team
  • Comey's defense team is challenging the legality of Halligan's appointment and filing motions regarding how she brought the indictment

Why it matters

  • This case is significant because it involves potential government misconduct in a politically charged prosecution of a former FBI Director who led investigations into the sitting president. The judge's findings suggest that fundamental misstatements of law may have compromised the grand jury process, which undermines the integrity of the justice system. The extraordinary remedy of granting full access to grand jury materials indicates serious judicial concern about whether proper legal procedures were followed, particularly given the rapid timeline from the prosecutor's appointment to indictment.

What's next

  • No explicit next steps stated in the article

Read full article from source: BBC